Ugrás a tartalomra
mobile

L'Harmattan Open Access platform

  • Keresés
  • OA Gyűjtemények
  • L'Harmattan Archívum
Magyarhu
  • Englishen
  • Françaisfr
  • Deutschde
BejelentkezésRegisztráció
  • Kötet áttekintése
  • Oldal
  • Szöveg
  • Metaadatok
  • Kivágás
Előnézet
022_000051/0000

Liber Amicorum Károly Bárd, II. Constraints on Government and Criminal Justice

  • Előnézet
  • PDF
  • Metaadatok mutatása
  • Permalink mutatása
Tudományterület
Jogtudomány / Law (12870), Jog, kriminológia, pönológia / Law, criminology, penology (12871), Emberi jogok / Human rights (12876)
Tudományos besorolás
tanulmánykötet
022_000051/0057
  • Kötet áttekintése
  • Oldal
  • Szöveg
  • Metaadatok
  • Kivágás
Oldal 58 [58]
  • Előnézet
  • Permalink mutatása
  • JPG
  • TIFF
  • Előző
  • Következő
022_000051/0057

OCR

VIOLETA BESIREVIÉ crimes.$ AIl other non-legal aspirations are notably missing. Was that the sign that lessons were learned and that associating non-legal purposes, like peacebuilding or reconciliation, with international justice mechanisms impeded international criminal justice rather than advanced it? To explore the issue, I will pit the Nurnberg “International” Military Tribunal (IMT) mandate against the ICTY mandate. I have deliberately decided to compare the two legacies, not only because I am emotionally attached to the region of the former Yugoslavia, but also because the ICTY was the first modern tribunal established after the Nuremberg. An additional reason also urges parallel assessment of their mandates — the criticisms leveled against the IMT and the ICTY were to some extent the same, in the sense that they were ad hoc bodies designed to administer justice selectively.’ ACCOMPLISHED MISSIONS: INTERNATIONAL CRIMINALIZATION OF ATROCITIES Much ink has been spilled in regards to the Nuremberg trail. On many occasions, the Nuremberg legacy has been subjected to methodical evaluation that resulted in divided opinions on almost every aspect of the trial.’ For some, Nuremberg was a great success, a milestone in international criminal law. To its critics, Nuremberg was a failure, a mere victor’s justice in which ex post facto substantive rules were applied under novel jurisdictional theories.’ There are conflicting views on whether the trial was procedurally fair." There is much to be said about the Nuremberg trial, but this chapter’s space and purpose do not allow me to assess all aspects of the trial deeply. Instead, I will focus on the predominant concern of this chapter — the IMT mandate and the issue of what Nuremberg was about. ° See the Preamble of the Rome Statute. 7 Claus Kress, The International Criminal Court as a Turning Point in the History of International Criminal Justice, in Antonio Cassese (ed.), The Oxford Companion to International Criminal Justice, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2009, 143-159. The scholarship on the Nuremberg trial and the IMT is immense. I would like to draw attention to the 1995 New York Law School Journal of Human Rights symposium: Panel I: Telford Taylor Panel: Critical Perspectives on the Nuremberg Trials, New York Law School Journal of Human Rights 12 (1995), 453-544; Donna E. Arzt, Nuremberg, Denazification and Democracy: The Hate Speech Problem at the International Military Tribunal, New York Law School Journal of Human Rights 12 (1995), 689-758. See discussion of Jonathan Bush in Panel I: Telford Taylor Panel: Critical Perspectives on the Nuremberg Trials, 461. 10 Arzt, Nuremberg, Denazification and Democracy, 702. +56 +

Szerkezeti

Custom

Image Metadata

Kép szélessége
1949 px
Kép magassága
2776 px
Képfelbontás
300 px/inch
Kép eredeti mérete
1.13 MB
Permalinkből jpg
022_000051/0057.jpg
Permalinkből OCR
022_000051/0057.ocr

Linkek

  • L'Harmattan Könyvkiadó
  • Open Access Blog
  • Kiadványaink az MTMT-ben
  • Kiadványaink a REAL-ban
  • CrossRef Works
  • ROR ID

Elérhetőség

  • L'Harmattan Szerkesztőség
  • Kéziratleadási szabályzat
  • Peer Review Policy
  • Adatvédelmi irányelvek
  • Dokumentumtár
  • KBART lists
  • eduID Belépés

Social media

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

L'Harmattan Open Access platform

BejelentkezésRegisztráció

Bejelentkezés

eduId Login
Elfelejtettem a jelszavamat
  • Keresés
  • OA Gyűjtemények
  • L'Harmattan Archívum
Magyarhu
  • Englishen
  • Françaisfr
  • Deutschde